Share this article:
Print

$100M lawsuit blames Toyota for deaths of Clear Lake couple

Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.

by Chris Paschenko / The Daily News

khou.com

Posted on February 17, 2010 at 10:34 AM

Updated Wednesday, Feb 17 at 7:08 PM

LEAGUE CITY, Texas — A $100 million wrongful-death lawsuit claims a Clear Lake City couple died after their Toyota Camry’s throttle malfunctioned, causing the car to accelerate and crash into a utility pole.

The lawsuit comes as Toyota conducts a recall of 6 million automobiles in the U.S. to repair sticking throttles. It is the largest recall in the automaker’s history and among the top 10 of all time.

Janice H. Berg bought a 2009 Camry in December 2008 from Star Toyota in League City, according to a lawsuit filed Monday in Galveston’s 122nd District Court by Wayne D. Collins on behalf of Berg’s son, Kenneth E. Hall.

On Feb. 24, Berg, 79, was driving south on El Camino Real in Clear Lake City with her husband, Kenneth D. Berg Sr., 85, the lawsuit claims.

Suddenly, the car malfunctioned and accelerated at a high rate of speed, the lawsuit claims. Janice Berg lost control at an intersection and crashed into a utility pole.

The cause of the crash was inconclusive, Collins said of a police report.

‘It Didn’t Make Sense’

"Some of the eyewitnesses who saw it accelerate ... said it didn’t make sense they were going that fast," Collins said.

First responders used hydraulic tools to pull Janice Burg from the car, and medical records state she was in severe pain upon arrival at Ben Taub General Hospital, the lawsuit claims.

The Burgs died that night, claims the lawsuit, which names Star Toyota, Toyota Motor Sales U.S.A., CTS Corp. and Gulf States Toyota.

Attempts to reach Star Toyota and Toyota Motor Sales for comment were unsuccessful.

Some months later, Hall received in his mother’s mail a letter from Toyota to inform her that the gas pedal of her Camry could get stuck on the all-weather floor mats, causing a dangerous situation, the lawsuit claims.

Toyota attempted to cover up the dangerous defects in many of its vehicles, first blaming driver inattentiveness in April 2009, then the floor mats months later, the lawsuit claims.

The National Highway Transportation Safety Administration criticized Toyota in November for making misleading claims related to the floor mat recall, the lawsuit claims.

Aware Of Defects In ’07?

Toyota’s vehicle recall to repair or replace the accelerator pedal was the largest in the company’s history, the lawsuit claims.

"Subsequently, it has been allegedly discovered that Toyota was aware of problems with gas pedal sensors, causing sudden vehicle acceleration in many of its vehicles as early as March 2007, the lawsuit claims.

The National Highway Transportation Safety Administration announced Tuesday it would use its statutory authority to obtain documents from Toyota to learn if the automaker made three of its recent recalls in a timely manner.

Federal law requires all automobile manufacturers to within five days notify the administration that a safety defect exists, the administration stated.

6 Million U.S. Cars Recalled

The administration is requiring Toyota to provide documents showing when and how it learned of the defects affecting about 6 million vehicles in the United States.

The administration also is probing whether Toyota discovered the problems before or after the automobiles were built.

The three recalls involve Toyota and Lexus vehicles, including the 2007 through 2010 Camry for gas pedal entrapment by floor mats and sticky gas pedals, the administration states.

The administration is probing whether Toyota has covered all affected models to ensure the automaker, "didn’t miss any problems," according to Tuesday’s statement.

If the auto safety agency finds a manufacturer violated its statutory obligations, the manufacturer could be liable for a maximum $16.4 million in civil penalties, the administration states.

Collins’ lawsuit seeks a sum not less than $100 million plus interest and attorney and other fees.

 

Share this article:
Print

To add a comment, please register or login.

Leave your comment
1000 characters remaining

Submit

We welcome your comments on this story's topic. Off-topic comments, personal attacks, and inappropriate language may be flagged and removed, and comment privileges blocked, per our Terms of Service. Thanks for keeping the comments space respectful.

Privacy Policy

HTML is not allowed.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Comments: Displaying 1 - 15 of 22

oilfieldtrash said on February 17, 2010 at 6:58 PM

I don't think the $100 million has much to do with the lawsuit. It represents nothing more than a random figure to garner headlines. This case will settle with a mere fraction of that. Unfortunately our society has no real way to punish for these type of things other than rediculous lawsuits. It's not like you can take Toyotas phone away for 3 months, or ground them for a year.

37782346
Flag this comment

cplmom1 said on February 17, 2010 at 5:15 PM

I am sorry that this man lost his mother but is $100 million going to bring them back???

37776738
Flag this comment

graro said on February 17, 2010 at 4:54 PM

nothing heals a broken heart like a fat paycheck...apparently.

37775276
Flag this comment

imalady2 said on February 17, 2010 at 4:17 PM

lol @ raymon: As you wanted, I'm sure your online friends will throw a big party for you. No worries - so rest in peace with a smile on your face, when your time comes.

37772477
Flag this comment

mrsanchez said on February 17, 2010 at 4:11 PM

I BET THE DRIVER HIT THE ACCELERATOR IN STEAD OF THE BREAK THATS WHAT ELDERLY PEOPLE DO. THOUSANDS OF ACCIDENTS ON RECORD OF THIS PEOPLE ARE DOING AND SAYING ANYTHING ABOUT THIS RECALL,THEY ARE JUST MONEY HUNGRY PERSONS! GET A LIFE INSURANCE POLICY.GEEEEEZZ THERE IS NOTHING WRONG WITH MY 2009 CAMERY! AND IF IT DECIDES TO GO ON IT OWN DUH PUT IT IN THE N POSITION . COME ON MR. HALL GET BACK TO YOUR JOB LIKE THE REST OF US INSTEAD OF TRYING TO GET RICH ON THE UNFORTUNATE DEATH OF YOU PARENTS . YOU PROBABLY WENT OUT AND BOUGHT IT AFTER THE RECALL FOR THEM

37771941
Flag this comment

vet2be1973 said on February 17, 2010 at 4:09 PM

$100M? Looks like the fat cat snake attorneys are going to make a fortune off of this. Out of that $100M, they'll get $30M free and clear, and then tack on another $10M for "expenses." Yes, there should be tort reform, and it should begin with attorney fees.

37771831
Flag this comment

txchick1971 said on February 17, 2010 at 3:34 PM

i own a matrix and a tacoma and have owned a camry. These are the best cars I've ever driven and owned. Too bad the prices are gonna go up now because of all the lawsuits. I hate to see that.

37769401
Flag this comment

raymon said on February 17, 2010 at 3:27 PM

100 million is nothing! My suit is for 100 billion because a runaway Toyota killed me! With all of the publicity, I pre-taped this e-mail and my future wishes if this should happen! Throw me a party, I'll be watching!

37768923
Flag this comment

imalady2 said on February 17, 2010 at 3:06 PM

This matter may likely be directed into becoming a class action lawsuit, as many more plaintiffs come forward to file claims against Toyota -(even wishful thinkers of financial victory) which ultimately brings the individual plaintiff settlement/awards down to peanut size (and a couple of million $$ is a small award in these times of litigation frenzy.) I don't know if this is to be about the emotionalism of losing a loved one as much as it becomes hard economics. The emotionalism is a cruel mind game that the victims must face - we all know the lives of our loved ones are priceless and irreplaceable, but the American way (unfortunatelty) is that cold cash can and does make it easier to "find closure" or "move on".......and somebody will have to put a # on that emotionalism....and still, it is the lawyers who always win. These lawsuits will go on, most likely, for years to drain the claims and then Toyota could file Chapter 11 to restructure around them.

37767363
Flag this comment

redwine said on February 17, 2010 at 3:02 PM

This is the real reason that American companies are relocating overseas. As 80 year old couple gets in a wreck and it must be the car's fault. Even if they lose the lawyers and legal system will make money on this and the rest of us will pay.

37767022
Flag this comment

apollo said on February 17, 2010 at 2:58 PM

What is the price of a life worth? How bout we multiply the dead person's life insurance by 10. Doesn't it make sense that they ought to carry enough to take care of their family? So, why would they be worth 100 million dollars if they carry 10K, 100K or 1 mil on their own life. Of course lawyers would never agree, but it is an easy formula.

37766692
Flag this comment

stephaniet02 said on February 17, 2010 at 2:37 PM

My question to all that question the age of those that have died or the response time to react is: What is your life worth? Or the life of your children, parents, siblings..ect...? Toyota is responsible for building safe cars, they have failed at their job, they should pay..simple as that.

37765151
Flag this comment

la_diabla_tejana said on February 17, 2010 at 1:47 PM

any of you stock investors, now would be the beautiful time to invest in toyota stock, they'll rebound after all this mess is said and done with...unless every vehicle they made needs to be recalled...which its turning out to be rather quickly.

37761111
Flag this comment

houstonative78 said on February 17, 2010 at 1:25 PM

toyota = murder

37759471
Flag this comment

misterbojangles said on February 17, 2010 at 12:51 PM

100M, PUHLEASE, COULD ALSO BE GOD SAID TIME FOR YOU BOTH TO COME HOME ????

37756601
Flag this comment

dixiechick said on February 17, 2010 at 12:43 PM

There really is no price on a life and Toyota is responsible. When you put your trust in a product you buy and it fails you with the cost of your life, they need to be held accountable. Further, regarding the price, think about it this way: what DO you think is a fair price? Then, think about selling your son, daughter, mother, father, spouse at an auction for that amount. Is that what their life is worth to you? Also, I'm thinking people generally get 1/3 or less of what they ask for with an occassional exception. Yes, it is an outrageous amount.

37755967
Flag this comment

outthere2 said on February 17, 2010 at 12:25 PM

Has anyone checked the car to see if this gas pedal was actually sticking? I have seen 85 year olds drive, its not pretty. I am sorry for this families loss but their parents lives/deaths are not worth $100 million dollars. When i saw the reports on the recalls, i could just picture the lawyers drooling and the wheels turning in their heads. They told their wives to break out the wish list because they were going to get rich off of this.

37754418
Flag this comment

jjdoxy said on February 17, 2010 at 11:59 AM

I am very sorry for the tragic loss but 100M? Get real, no one is worth that. And the lawyer will get most of it.

37752206
Flag this comment

boondocksaint said on February 17, 2010 at 11:54 AM

Yes some gas pedals are sticking but what about that elderly man in California who hit the gas pedal instead of his brake and slammed into a crowd of people killing several. This has happened several time with other older people. Plus, when the attorney for toyota puts a price on their lives the amount will go down. There is enough doubt in my mind that they may have caused the accident.

37751793
Flag this comment

apollo said on February 17, 2010 at 11:45 AM

Have you ever ridden with a person that age? Maybe 1% of this age group should even have a license. The car accelerated because gramma or grampa hit the gas. Duh.

37750976
Flag this comment

daisymay said on February 17, 2010 at 11:28 AM

And we're OFF! On the lawsuit bandwagon. I can't wait for the commercials to start seekng more clients. I wonder what this 85 and 79 year old couple did as a job? I don't even think the President of the United States of America's life is worth $100 Million. These were elderly senior citizens, and although it's sad that they were killed, who is to say their lack of response time and reflexes weren't the reason for the crash? I just hate that people try to replace loved ones with cash. Yuck.

37749702
Flag this comment

rf2002 said on February 17, 2010 at 11:05 AM

Another one and I see many more to be filed. Toyota has to be held responsible as a vehicle is not a toy that can only cause minor injuries if malfunctioned.

37748098
Flag this comment