CMA Awards: Who should win, who will win

The competition is friendly but fierce at Wednesday's Country Music Association Awards, which air live on ABC at 8 p.m. ET. Here are our picks for who will take home the night's top prizes — and the performers who also deserve the recognition.

Entertainer of the Year

Will win: Luke Bryan/Garth Brooks

Should win: Carrie Underwood

The concert industry makes up a huge portion of the CMA voter base, and no one’s ruled that world like Brooks and Bryan in the last year. Since returning to the road in 2014, Brooks is closing in on 5 million tickets sold. On the other hand, Bryan has the momentum of winning the award for the last two years – and an endless string of modern hits.

But an Underwood win is long overdue. Not just for the singer – who’s been one of the genre’s most recognizable stars for a decade now – but for female performers in general. Much has been made of modern country music being unfairly dominated by its male stars, and considering that Underwood has somehow never been nominated for Entertainer of the Year before, it’s hard to argue.

Male Vocalist of the Year

Will win: Chris Stapleton

Should win: Dierks Bentley

If you’ve heard him wail Sometimes I Cry in concert, it’s hard to imagine the incredible Stapleton losing any award with “vocalist” in the title. But as a performer and ambassador for the genre, Bentley has been a steadfast star, and one that continues to take risks that pay off like the uncharacteristic hit Somewhere on a Beach.

 

Female Vocalist of the Year

Will and should win: Carrie Underwood

Despite some formidable competition, Underwood seems like a shoe-in for this award, especially since longtime winner Miranda Lambert had a relatively quiet year.

New Artist of the Year

Will win: Kelsea Ballerini

Should win: Maren Morris

This category’s truly a toss-up. Few newcomers in recent memory seem as poised to be a longtime star as Ballerini, who’s had three consecutive No. 1 hits, including the stellar Peter Pan. But in terms of bringing something “new” to the table, Morris has no peer in the category. Her Hero album mixed a reverence for classic country and a penchant for modern pop hooks, and made her one of the night’s top nominees. If there’s a category for her to win, this is it.

Song of the Year

Will and should win: Humble and Kind, Lori McKenna

The Tim McGraw hit is universally adored by the industry, and the melody and message (to “always stay humble and kind”) penned by McKenna clicked with millions of listeners and turned into an anthem for its singer.

Single of the Year

Will and should win:Die a Happy Man, Thomas Rhett

A winning blend of sentimental songwriting, slick production and a smooth vocal from Thomas Rhett. Die a Happy Man topped the country charts, earned critical raves and picked up a similar award from the Academy of Country Music earlier this year.

Album of the Year

Will win:Storyteller, Carrie Underwood

Should win:Mr. Misunderstood, Eric Church

Storyteller has the commercial success and admirable sonic cohesion, but with Mr. Misunderstood, Church turned his album into event. Its surprise release — revealed during last year’s CMAs — is a move that pop stars have pulled for years now, but few country acts are daring to attempt.

Vocal Group of the Year

Will and should win: Little Big Town

The beloved country quartet have owned this award since 2012, and despite Old Dominion breathing new life into a category that’s always in need of it, we’re betting the streak will continue.

Vocal Duo of the Year

Will and should win: Florida Georgia Line

They have their share of detractors, but Tyler Hubbard and Brian Kelley have been very, very good for the country music business. The duo has packed arenas, performed for millions and just went double platinum with their single H.O.L.Y.



JOIN THE CONVERSATION

To find out more about Facebook commenting please read the
Conversation Guidelines and FAQs

Leave a Comment